← Back to your puzzle
EXPERT TECHNIQUE

X-Wing.

An X-Wing is the smallest of the fish patterns. Pick one digit and find two rows in which it has exactly two possible squares, with those squares sitting in the same two columns. The two placements must form a diagonal, so the digit can be struck from the rest of both columns. It is the first Expert technique on Sudoku Dawn and the gateway to the larger fish.

What it is

Fish patterns are about a single digit. For an X-Wing you need two base rows where the digit has exactly two candidate squares each, and the four squares must line up in two columns, forming the corners of a rectangle. Whichever corner the first row uses, the second row must use the opposite column, so the two columns each receive exactly one of these two digits.

That is the whole deduction: each of the two columns will get its copy of the digit from one of the base rows, so no other square in either column can hold it. The pattern works just as well with two base columns and two cover rows; the solver checks both orientations.

How to spot it

Scan digit by digit, looking for rows with exactly two candidates for that digit. Note the columns of each pair. When two rows share the same pair of columns, you have the rectangle. Then look down both columns, outside the two base rows, for pencil notes of the digit to remove.

The pattern is most common in the middle of a puzzle, once singles and locks have thinned the candidates but several digits still have two or three places in most rows. Digits that have already been placed six or seven times are the best bets.

  • Choose a digit and list the rows where it has exactly two possible squares.
  • Compare the column pairs of those rows; two rows that share both columns form an X-Wing.
  • Remove the digit from every other square in those two columns.
  • Repeat with columns as the base lines and rows as the cover lines.

Why it works

Each base row needs the digit exactly once, and in both rows it can only go in the two cover columns. Two rows, two copies of the digit, two columns: if both copies fell in the same column, that column would hold the digit twice, which the rules forbid. So one copy goes in each column, and each column has its digit accounted for by the base rows. Any other square in those columns that still shows the digit is therefore wrong.

The name comes from the picture: drawing the two possible placements gives two diagonals that cross in an X. The deduction never says which diagonal is the real one; it only removes candidates in the cover lines, and the payoff is the single that follows.

Worked example

This example comes from an Expert puzzle generated by Sudoku Dawn, after the singles are placed. In the two shaded rows the digit 1 has exactly two places each, in the same two columns. The struck-through 1 in one of those columns, outside the shaded rows, is removed, and with it gone the 1 has only one place left in that square’s row.

In rows 4 and 5, the 1 can only go in columns 4 and 8. Those two rows need two 1s, one in each of columns 4 and 8, so row 8, column 8 can't be 1.

From a Sudoku Dawn Expert puzzle, after the singles are placed.

Shaded squares form the pattern. Bold small numbers are the pattern’s candidates. Struck-through numbers are removed by this deduction. Bold large digits are the puzzle’s givens.

Common mistakes

A row with three possible squares for the digit is not a base row for an X-Wing, even if two of them line up with another row. The base rows must have exactly two places each; three places need a Swordfish with a third row.

The removals happen in the cover columns, outside the base rows, never inside the rectangle itself. The four corner squares keep their candidates until a later single decides them.

Check that the two rows are different rows and the two columns are different columns. Two candidates in a single row are a pair of places, not a wing.

Where it appears in Sudoku Dawn

The X-Wing is the first fish the solver tries, directly after the Hard techniques. A puzzle that needs one is rated Expert. The coach titles the step An X-Wing, and its nudge asks you to look at where the digit can go in the two base lines; the explanation names the lines, states that the two lines need two copies of the digit, one in each cover line, and lists the removals before continuing to the single they expose.